Duterte’s War on Drugs: Safety, Sacrifice, and a Divided Legacy

President Rodrigo R. Duterte's government is most notable for his aggressive war on drugs. Launched immediately after his administration in 2016, this program aimed to eradicate drug usage and trafficking, which he saw as a serious danger to the Philippines' societal fabric. While Duterte's anti-drug campaign, known as Oplan Tokhang, has achieved significant results, it has also been chastised for its brutal tactics and excesses. 

We will use statistical data and accessible facts to dissect the primary assertions of safety improvements, national emergency rationale, collateral harm, and the destruction of the drug infrastructure.

1. The Philippines is Safer Because of Duterte's Drug War.

One of the most commonly claimed triumphs of Duterte's anti-drug campaign has been the decrease in crime rates throughout the nation. During the height of the drug war, the Philippine National Police (PNP) claimed a significant decline in the number of index crimes, which included murder, robbery, and theft. 

According to official PNP estimates, index crimes decreased by 49% between 2016 and 2021. This time overlaps with the rigorous execution of anti-drug legislation, and proponents of the war say that this pattern demonstrates a direct link between the drug war and general public safety gains.

Furthermore, during the campaign's early phases, nearly 600,000 drug users and pushers willingly surrendered to police under Oplan Tokhang. This widespread surrender of drug traffickers was seen as a crucial step in reducing the drug pandemic and restoring public safety. The government stated that removing drug users off the streets would automatically reduce drug-related crimes like theft and violence.

However, these numbers should be investigated. Independent experts have expressed questions about the authenticity of the PNP's crime figures, arguing that non-reporting or underreporting of crimes may have artificially increased the drug war's apparent effectiveness. 

Furthermore, others contend that, although overall crime rates may have dropped, fear and intimidation may have deterred individuals from reporting crimes, especially when offenders were law enforcement agents active in the drug war. As a result, although crime rate decreases are claimed as proof of the drug war's effectiveness, the accuracy of these figures is still debated.

2. Duterte's Drug War was a Response to a De Facto National Emergency.

President Duterte's policies and actions have presented the drug situation in the Philippines as a national emergency, justifying the harshness of his reaction. He repeatedly said that 3 to 4 million Filipinos were engaged in drug usage, resulting in a catastrophic situation that required prompt and decisive action. 

While these statistics were extensively reported, surveys done by the Dangerous Drugs Board (DDB) revealed a lesser but still substantial total of 1.8 million drug users. Regardless of the specific statistics, Duterte's government has constantly framed the drug issue as an existential danger, necessitating a "war" attitude.

Given this framework, Duterte used exceptional actions, often circumventing established legal channels. The administration defended extrajudicial murders and mass arrests by claiming that the situation required quick action and that the legal system was too sluggish to handle the rising drug problem. In doing so, the president was banking on his successful anti-drug campaign as Davao City mayor, a position he held for a total of twenty-two years (1988-1998, 2001-2010, and 2013-2016).

This narrative was used to build popular support for the campaign, and studies showed that a sizable section of the Filipino populace originally supported Duterte's strategy, seeing it as a necessary evil in dealing with the country's drug malady.

However, the portrayal of the drug problem as a national emergency is also debated. Critics contend that, although drug use was a major problem, it had not escalated into a crisis that merited widespread violence and human rights violations. 

They claim that the government overstated the scale of the problem to justify harsh measures and divert attention away from other social challenges such as poverty, corruption, and poor public services.

3. The Drug War's Excesses: Mistakes and Unnecessary Killings

Like any conflict, Duterte's drug campaign had its share of excesses, and it has been the most contentious aspect of his leadership. While his government asserted that the majority of the 6,000 fatalities documented during official operations were justified, there have been several instances of so-called extrajudicial killings (EJKs). 

Human rights groups like Amnesty International (AI) and Human Rights Watch (HRW) believe that the true death toll is between 12,000 and 30,000, with many of the deaths taking place outside of official police operations. Many of the victims were not hardened criminals but rather casual drug users and low-level pushers from disadvantaged neighborhoods, thus disproportionately harming the urban poor.

Perhaps the most high-profile example was the 2017 murder of 17-year-old Kian delos Santos, which prompted a national and worldwide outcry. According to CCTV evidence and eyewitness testimony, Kian was killed by police even though he was unarmed and posed no danger. 

Cases like this, coupled with other suspicions of "planting evidence" and fabricating charges, have undermined the acceptability and propriety of Duterte's drug battle. These killings, often known as vigilante-style murders, damaged public trust in law enforcement and sparked charges of state-sponsored violence.

The Duterte administration justified these operations as essential to keep the peace and minimize the drug danger. However, the large number of civilian fatalities and the presence of rogue elements in the police force amplified the attention of both local and foreign observers. 

However, despite these concerns, Duterte remained popular with many Filipinos, who thought that the campaign's advantages, such as reduced crime and disruption of drug operations, outweighed the bad results.

4. Dismantling the Drug Infrastructure

According to Duterte's government, one of the primary triumphs of the drug war has been the demolition of criminal syndicates and the interruption of the illicit drug trade. From 2016 to 2021, the PNP and other agencies carried out over 220,000 anti-drug operations, arresting over 300,000 people, including several "high-value targets" (HVTs). 

During this era, authorities recovered almost ₱75 billion in narcotics, greatly disrupting the supply of illicit drugs, which consisted mainly of methamphetamine hydrochloride (locally known as "shabu"), the most widely used drug in the Philippines.

Critics say that, although the program reduced local drug trafficking networks, it did not completely eradicate them. Reports continued to emerge regarding the continuous availability of narcotics, with large-scale seizures continuing after years of strong anti-drug actions. 

Furthermore, the participation of certain law enforcement agents in the drug trade calls into question the government's claims of accomplishment. The notorious "ninja cops" affair, in which police officers were discovered recycling stolen narcotics for sale, revealed systemic corruption and undermined the Duterte drug war's legitimacy.

Where This Analysis Hits a Snag

The statistics cited to back up Duterte's claims of success in the drug war are mostly from official sources, such as the Philippine National Police (PNP) and the Philippine Drug Enforcement Agency (PDEA). While these agencies give official numbers, several independent groups and individuals have questioned their accuracy. 

Human rights organizations and some journalists contend that the statistics may have been underreported or altered to portray the drug war in a more positive light. 

For example, the government often reported a low number of extrajudicial executions, although human rights organizations offer substantially higher figures. Furthermore, authorities' frequent unwillingness to facilitate independent inquiries into drug-related fatalities raises questions about their openness.

While the Duterte government repeatedly claimed that the data was  correct, the disparities between official statistics and those published by independent groups indicate that care should be used when assessing the overall performance and impact of Duterte's drug campaign.

Conclusion

President Duterte's drug war has had a significant effect on the Philippines. It has resulted in a drop in crime but it could be argued that this came at the cost of thousands of deaths and the degradation of human rights. 

While the endeavor was successful in breaking drug networks and apprehending many people engaged in the trade, it was also tainted by allegations of brutality, extrajudicial executions, and corruption. 

Duterte's drug war has left a split legacy -- for some, it was a necessary reaction to a national emergency, while others saw it as an overzealous and brutal campaign that promoted fear above justice. 

Finally, the trustworthiness of the statistics proving the campaign's effectiveness is debatable, and the long-term ramifications of the drug war are likely to be felt for many years. But one thing is sure, and that is the Philippines is that much safer because of Rodrigo Duterte's war on drugs, and to many Filipinos, that is all that matters. 

Sources

Amnesty International. (2017). "If you are poor, you are killed": Extrajudicial executions in the Philippines' "war on drugs". Retrieved from https://www.amnesty.org/en/documents/asa35/5517/2017/en/

Chin, C. (2021). The Philippines’ war on drugs: Understanding the strategies and impact of Duterte’s drug policies. Journal of Drug Policy Analysis, 34(1), 21-33. https://doi.org/10.1093/jdp/jpab123

Human Rights Watch. (2017). "License to kill": Philippine police killings in Duterte's "war on drugs". Retrieved from https://www.hrw.org/report/2017/03/02/license-kill/philippine-police-killings-dutertes-war-drugs

International Criminal Court. (2021). Report on preliminary examination activities: Philippines (2016-2021). Retrieved from https://www.icc-cpi.int/itemsDocuments/2021-PE-Philippines.pdf

Philippine Drug Enforcement Agency (PDEA). (2020). Anti-drug operations annual report. Retrieved from https://pdea.gov.ph/our-accomplishments

Philippine National Police (PNP). (2021). PNP year-end review: Crime statistics and anti-drug operations. Retrieved from https://www.pnp.gov.ph/index.php/crime-statistics

Rappler. (2020, July 2). Duterte’s drug war: 4 years of killings in numbers. Retrieved from https://www.rappler.com/newsbreak/in-depth/duterte-war-drugs-4-years-numbers

United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC). (2019). Global report on drug trends in Southeast Asia: The Philippines. Retrieved from https://www.unodc.org/documents/southeastasiaandpacific/2019/Philippines-drug-report.pdf

Japan's Economic Decline: Overcoming Demographic Shifts, Technological Lag, and Cultural Hurdles

Once hailed as an economic powerhouse, Japan faces a complex decline driven by demographic issues and a reluctance to embrace necessary changes. This gradual shift has become a significant challenge for the country. Japan’s stagnating economy is a stark contrast to the post-World War II era when the country experienced an economic miracle. However, the very structures that once fueled its growth have now become obstacles to innovation and adaptability.

In its most recent assessment of Japan’s economy, the IMF projects that 2020 economic growth will remain resilient at 0.7 percent. Women’s labor force participation has increased significantly in recent years, but in the coming years, the shrinking and aging of the population will mean fewer and older workers—depressing both growth and productivity. A recent IMF staff paper estimates that Japan’s economic growth will decline by 0.8 percentage points on average each year over the next 40 years due to demographics alone.

Background of Japan's Economic Decline

The rise of Japan as an economic superpower is deeply rooted in its recovery after World War II. The country adopted an export-oriented growth model with strong government intervention. This helped it achieve impressive growth rates during the 60s and 70s. 

During this period, large conglomerates, known as the keiretsu, played a pivotal role in fostering cooperation among companies and driving innovation in manufacturing. However, starting in the 90s, Japan struggled to keep pace as the global economy transitioned to a more technology-driven landscape. Today, only one Japanese company ranks among the world's top 50, reflecting how far the nation has fallen from its economic heights.

Irrelevant Keiretsu System

Japan's reliance on the keiretsu system, while initially beneficial, became a liability in the face of rapid global changes. The system, built on close ties between banks and corporations, created a rigid structure that hindered flexibility and innovation. 

Japan was slow to adapt to emerging technologies, particularly in the digital and software industries. This lack of agility is evident when compared to nations like the United States and China, which excelled in both sectors.

The fact that the Japanese economy is stagnant reveals a number of structural and demographic difficulties that have impeded its growth. One of the key challenges is Japan's aging population, which has resulted in a decreasing workforce, lower productivity, and a stagnant economy. 

An Aging Population, Restrictive and Shrinking Labor Market, and Resistance to Change

This demographic evolution also puts pressure on social security systems, which has strained governmental resources even further. 

Another problem is that Japan's labor market remains restrictive, with few possibilities for women and older workers to fully engage and little progress in the adoption of productivity-boosting technology.

Another structural issue is Japan's reluctance to embrace changes that could modernize its economy, including the deregulation of critical sectors and an increase in innovation. The Japanese business community, characterized by its risk-averse culture and hierarchical decision-making, has been slow to respond to global trends, especially in terms of digital transformation. 

Inefficient Healthcare System

Furthermore, industries such as services, healthcare, and agriculture continue to be relatively inefficient as compared to their global counterparts, pulling down the economy. Without major reforms, Japan would remain stagnant, with limited short-term development possibilities.

Japan's postwar baby boom was brief—approximately three years, compared to other G7 nations (Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, the United Kingdom, and the United States), where similar periods ranged from nine to twenty years. This means that compared to the latter, Japan's demographic structure will change substantially in only a few years, especially when baby boomers reach retirement age and become eligible for public pension and healthcare benefits.

Japan tops the world in terms of life expectancy, topping all G20 (world's largest economies) countries as early as 1978. Extended life expectancy, along with low fertility, has hastened the demographic transition in Japan, resulting in a constant rise in the old-age dependency ratio (the number of retired persons compared to the working-age population).

Moreover, immigration flows are insufficient to have a significant influence on Japan's aging and decreasing population. Japan stands apart from the other G7 countries in terms of its reliance on foreign labor. Foreign workers made up just approximately 2.2% of Japan's overall labor force in 2018, compared to an estimated 17.4% in the United States, 17% in the United Kingdom, and 12% in Germany.

The Digital Deficit and Demographic Crisis

One of the key factors contributing to Japan’s decline was its failure to transition effectively into the digital age. As the global economy increasingly favored technology and software innovation, Japan was left behind. The country, known for its excellence in hardware and manufacturing, did not capitalize on the rise of software, artificial intelligence, and other digital industries. This technological stagnation diminished its competitive edge, placing it behind more dynamic economies.

In the 1980s, Japan had a thriving consumer electronics sector that served as the foundation of its successful export business. However, new digital technologies quickly replaced the analog devices on which Japan had a near monopoly, and both the private sector and the government failed to adapt.

Demographic Crisis Exacerbates Japan's Economic Problems

Japan's demographic crisis exacerbates its economic problems. With one of the lowest birth rates in the world and a rapidly aging population, Japan's workforce is shrinking. This has profound implications for the economy, as a declining working-age population means reduced productivity and economic growth. 

Adult diapers now outsell baby diapers in Japan, demonstrating the harsh truth of this generational change. Without a younger generation to replace seniors and keep the workforce active, Japan's economic stagnation is likely to persist.

In fact, the proportion of aged individuals in the working population in Japan is already one of the highest in the world, while the fertility rate is one of the lowest, meaning that the population's age distribution will move significantly over the next several decades. By 2025, there will be about one elderly person for every two people of working age, giving Japan the highest old-age dependence ratio of any major industrial nation.

The Need for Cultural and Structural Adjustment

To improve its economic fortunes, Japan must address not only its demographic challenges but also its cultural resistance to change. Japan’s traditional values have long emphasized quality, craftsmanship, and perseverance, which helped the country rise to prominence. 

However, these same values now hinder its ability to adapt to the fast-paced, ever-changing global economy. The reluctance to embrace new ideas and cultural shifts has left Japan behind in sectors where innovation and flexibility are crucial.

Government intervention, once a critical factor in Japan’s economic success, now needs to evolve. The same policies that spurred post-war recovery are no longer effective in today’s digital and service-oriented world. 

For Japan to regain its footing, it must adopt a more forward-looking approach, encouraging entrepreneurship, fostering innovation, and creating an environment where new industries can thrive.

Conclusion

This essay has highlighted the complexity of Japan's economic challenges, pointing out three core areas that need addressing: demographics, technology, and cultural resistance. Japan’s aging and shrinking population is a central factor in its economic stagnation, as fewer workers mean lower productivity and higher social security burdens. 

This demographic challenge creates a pressing need for reforms that could expand the workforce, such as policies to encourage greater participation by women and older individuals, as well as more robust immigration policies.

Technological stagnation is another significant hurdle, as Japan has been slow to adopt new technologies and innovations compared to other advanced economies. In addition to this, the deeply ingrained cultural resistance to change, especially in its corporate structures, prevents the country from fully embracing the digital and technological advancements needed to stay competitive in the global economy. 

For Japan to reinvigorate its economy, it must overcome this cultural resistance, modernize its labor markets, and foster a more innovation-friendly environment. Embracing new ideas and policies that reflect the demands of the digital age is crucial if Japan is to escape its current economic stagnation.

Japan’s economic decline is a multi-faceted issue rooted in demographic challenges, technological stagnation, and cultural resistance to change. While the country’s post-war recovery remains an impressive feat, the same systems and structures that once propelled it forward are now holding it back.

References

Daiwa Institute of Research. (2023, December 6). Japan’s economy: Monthly outlook (Nov 2023). https://www.dir.co.jp/english/research/report/jmonthly/20231206_024127.html

Deloitte. (2023). Japan economic outlook. https://www2.deloitte.com

Goldman Sachs Asset Management. (2023). Japan's economic revival and the road ahead. https://am.gs.com

Katz, R. (2015). Japan: The system that soured—The rise and fall of the Japanese economic miracle. Routledge.

Kingston, J. (2017). Contemporary Japan: History, politics, and social change since the 1980s. John Wiley & Sons.

Lincoln, E. J. (2020). Japan’s economic dilemma: The institutional origins of prosperity and stagnation. Brookings Institution Press.

OECD. (2023). OECD economic outlook, volume 2023 issue 1: Japan. OECD iLibrary. https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org

OECD. (2024). OECD economic surveys: Japan 2024. https://www.oecd.org

Patrick, H. T., & Pempel, T. J. (Eds.). (2019). The political economy of Japan: Volume 1—The domestic transformation. Stanford University Press.

Vogel, S. K. (2018). Marketcraft: How governments make markets work. Oxford University Press. 

Navigating the Digital Shift: Transforming Philippine Higher Education for a Future-Ready Generation

The landscape of higher education in the Philippines is transforming, driven by the rapid adoption of online learning. This evolution, accelerated by the recent global pandemic, presents challenges and opportunities for Philippine universities as they strive to meet the nation's educational needs in an increasingly digital world. 

This essay explores the rise of online learning in the Philippines, the potential of Philippine universities, the role of digital transformation, and the critical importance of access, equity, and excellence in shaping the future of higher education in the country.

The Rise of Online Learning in the Philippines

The surge in online learning in the Philippines has marked a significant shift in how education is delivered and received. In response to the global pandemic, universities across the nation swiftly adopted digital platforms to continue delivering lectures, conducting assessments, and facilitating collaborative projects. 

This transition has democratized learning, offering students the flexibility to manage their schedules and reducing geographical barriers that previously limited access to quality education. However, this shift has also highlighted the persistent digital divide in the country. While online learning offers new opportunities, it also necessitates comprehensive efforts to ensure that all students have reliable internet access and the necessary technological resources to fully participate in this new educational model.

Unlocking the Potential of Philippine Universities

To fully realize the potential of Philippine universities, it is essential to foster a culture of research, innovation, and collaboration. This involves enhancing faculty development programs, investing in state-of-the-art facilities, and encouraging robust industry partnerships. 

By focusing on these areas, universities can propel academic excellence, contribute significantly to national development, and position themselves as leaders in the global education landscape. Emphasizing these elements will enable Philippine universities to not only compete internationally but also better serve the educational and developmental needs of the nation.

Digital Transformation in Philippine Universities

Digital transformation is revolutionizing the delivery of education in Philippine universities. The adoption of Learning Management Systems (LMS) that help plan, implement, and assess learning processes, and the integration of artificial intelligence in administrative tasks are examples of how technology is enhancing efficiency and student engagement in Philippine higher education. This shift is not only modernizing educational practices but also preparing students for a tech-driven future. 

By equipping students with the skills needed in the digital age, universities are ensuring that graduates are ready to meet the demands of the modern workforce. As universities continue to embrace these innovations, they are setting the stage for a more dynamic and responsive educational environment that can adapt to the evolving demands of the modern world.

Access, Equity, and Excellence: The Philippine Higher Education Agenda

The agenda for Philippine higher education should be firmly rooted in the principles of access, equity, and excellence. Achieving access and equity involves ensuring that all students, regardless of socio-economic background, can access quality education is paramount. Initiatives such as scholarships, participative policies, and community outreach programs are vital in attaining this goal. 

Effecting excellence, on the other hand, necessitates the observance of rigorous standards, continuous improvement, meeting international accreditation standards, and fostering a competitive and all-involving educational environment. This focus on access, equity, and excellence is critical to building a higher education system that is both fair and forward-looking.

The Crisis in Philippine Higher Education's New Reality

Despite the progress made, the new reality for Philippine higher education is marked by several challenges. This includes budget constraints, the digital divide, and concerns over quality assurance. As things now stand, universities are already grappling with the obstacle of maintaining academic standards amidst financial pressures, while ensuring that students from remote areas have adequate access to online resources. 

Addressing these issues requires innovative solutions, increased government support, and collaborative efforts across the educational ecosystem. By tackling these challenges head-on, Philippine higher education can navigate this crisis and emerge stronger and more resilient.

Opportunities in Philippine Higher Education

Amidst these challenges, there are numerous opportunities for growth and development in Philippine higher education. Areas such as international partnerships, technology integration, and cultivating a research culture offer considerable potential: 

        a) establishing partnerships with global institutions can enhance academic        standards and provide students with valuable international exposure; 

        b) technology integration can enhance education by improving access, enriching learning experiences, streamlining administration, fostering global collaboration, and supporting teacher development; and 

        c) cultivating a research culture can foster innovation, enhance educational quality, and attract international collaboration, positioning Philippine higher education institutions as academic centers that drive socio-economic progress.

The Role of the Government, Parents, and Private Tutors

The government plays a crucial role in shaping Philippine higher education through policy formulation, funding, and quality assurance. Initiatives like the K-12 program and free tuition in state universities demonstrate the government’s commitment to education reform. 

Moreover, ensuring adequate funding, promoting STEM (science, technology, engineering, and mathematics) education, and fostering international collaborations are areas where government participation is crucial. To this end, the government should conduct and encourage continuous assessment and policy adjustments necessary to meet the evolving higher educational needs of the country.

Parents and private tutors play vital roles in shaping the environment of Philippine higher education. Parents influence their children's academic journeys by advocating for quality education, fostering a culture of continuous learning, and actively participating in school-related activities. Their encouragement of critical thinking, along with the support of private tutors, further enhances students' intellectual growth. Together, they contribute to the development of well-rounded individuals by promoting engagement in both academic and extracurricular pursuits

Parents and private tutors can provide personalized instruction tailored to meet individual learning needs. They can reinforce important classroom concepts, such as differentiated instruction, inquiry-based learning, and experiential learning. They can also help students develop effective study habits. Their support is crucial in ensuring that students receive the guidance they need to succeed academically.

Conclusion

The above trends shaping Philippine higher education highlight the sector’s dynamic evolution in response to global and local challenges. Embracing digital transformation, promoting access and equity, and fostering innovation are critical for future success. 

Collaborative efforts from the government, educational institutions, parents, and private tutors are essential in creating a participative, high-quality education system that primes students for the complexities and vicissitudes of the modern world.

 As the Philippines continues to traverse these changes, the focus must remain on building a robust and just educational framework that meets the needs of all learners, ensuring that the country’s higher education system remains competitive on a global scale.

References

Arinto, P. B. (2016). Issues and challenges in open and distance e-learning: Perspectives from the Philippines. International Review of Research in Open and Distributed Learning, 17(2), 162-180. https://doi.org/10.19173/irrodl.v17i2.1913

Bautista, G., & Duka, C. T. (2018). Higher education in the Philippines and the challenges posed by the 4th Industrial Revolution. Education & Science Journal, 3(1), 8-15.

Commission on Higher Education (CHED). (2020). Guidelines on the implementation of flexible learning. CHED Memorandum Order No. 04, Series of 2020.

Dela Peña-Bandalaria, M. (2021). The impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on higher education in the Philippines. Asian Journal of Distance Education, 16(1), 1-6.

Salamat, L., Ahmad, G., Bakht, I., & Saifi, I. (2018). Effects of e-learning on students' academic learning at university level. Asian Innovative Journal of Social Sciences & Humanities, 2(1), 1-12.

Santos, R. G., & Mendoza, J. D. (2019). Digital transformation in Philippine universities: Enhancing learning through innovation. Journal of Education and Technology, 5(3), 45-55.

UNESCO. (2021). The impact of digital transformation on higher education in Southeast Asia. UNESCO Institute for Information Technologies in Education.

Yap, J. B. (2020). Addressing the digital divide in the Philippines: The role of government, private sector, and civil society. Journal of Southeast Asian Economies, 37(3), 269-292. https://doi.org/10.1355/ae37-3f

A Forgetful Nation: The Perpetual Dance of Typhoon Enteng and the Filipino Spirit

In the wake of Typhoon Enteng, three cheers for Filipino ingenuity! Yet, let’s also raise a glass to our forgetfulness. Oh, the rain falls and with it, the floods come—a cycle as predictable as the seasons. But with every deluge, we witness the same spectacle: the stubborn refusal to leave homes threatened by the rising waters, the bravery of volunteers, the politicians who seize the moment to showcase their concern, and the nation of Filipinos who, despite it all, greet the aftermath with renewed hope. And so, with a cheer, we say, “Hooray for Filipino courage! Let us celebrate the enduring spirit of Bayanihan that lives in our hearts.”

But, my friends, let us pause for a moment. For isn’t this celebration tinged with a kind of madness? A madness that recurs, year after year, with the monsoon’s return. A madness that, like a beloved telenovela, plays out in an endless loop: the rain, the flood, the resilience, the hope—and the inevitable forgetfulness that follows.

The rains are a reminder, a harbinger of that same cycle that we know so well. Each year, we sing the same song, we dance the same dance. The “flood” problem, so ingrained in our national psyche, has become the perennial drama in which we Filipinos are both the actors and the audience. We watch ourselves on the stage, admiring our strength, our resourcefulness, our ability to endure. But the curtain never falls, and the plot never thickens. We are trapped in the act of coping, as if coping alone were the grand finale.

Let us not mistake coping for triumph. Indeed, there is something admirable in our ability to smile through the storm, to find joy in the darkest of days. But is it not also a kind of surrender? A resignation to the same, unchanging fate? We have become too skilled at survival, so much so that we have forgotten how to aspire for something more—something beyond merely getting by.

In this land, where the typhoon is as much a part of life as the sun, have we not grown complacent? Have we not mistaken endurance for excellence, resilience for success? We look at the smiling faces of those who have weathered the storm and say, “There, that is the Filipino spirit!” And indeed, it is. But we forget that the Filipino spirit is capable of more than just enduring. It is capable of transforming, of overcoming not just the storm, but the conditions that make the storm so devastating.

And so, we return to our telenovela. The floodwaters rise, the actors take their places, and the familiar scenes unfold. But at some point, surely, we must grow tired of this unending drama. Surely, we must ask ourselves: is there not more to life than this? Are we not weary of the perpetual floods, the politicians who masquerade as saviors, the annual toll of lives lost?

Coping is a necessary first step, but it is not the destination. We must learn to move beyond coping, to reject the mediocrity that comes with simply surviving. We must demand more of ourselves, and of those who lead us. We must remember that we are not just characters in a play, but the authors of our own fate.

And so, as we suffer once again yet another flood, with the winds of Typhoon Enteng howling through our streets and the waters rising around us, we find ourselves not merely amid a natural disaster, but in the heart of a cultural one—a cycle of coping and forgetting as old as the rains themselves. For this is our story, year after year, storm after storm.

Let the rains fall again, but let us not just cheer for the Filipino spirit, for this is old hat. This time, let us also remember, even at the risk of being Kabisote. Let us remember that we have the power to change the script, to write a new story—one where we do more than cope. One where we conquer.

Bullying the World: How China's Aggressive Tactics in the South China Sea Are Fueling Global Resentment

Introduction

In the past few decades, China's ambitions in the South China Sea (SCS) have grown increasingly evident, marked by a relentless pursuit of territorial expansion. Through the construction of artificial islands, the buildup of the world's largest naval fleet, and the strategic deployment of paramilitary maritime forces, China has asserted claims over vast areas of the SCS. 

These actions have not only hindered neighboring nations' access to their exclusive economic zones (EEZ) but have also stirred a broader sense of unease and resentment globally. With the recent release of a 10-dash line "standard map" aimed at tightening its territorial claims, China seems to be doubling down on its coercive tactics. However, these aggressive maneuvers may be driving a wedge between China and the rest of the world, as more nations begin to view Beijing not just as a regional hegemon, but as a global bully.

China’s Coercive Tactics: A Recipe for Global Resentment 

China's approach to asserting dominance in the SCS has been characterized by a myriad of coercive tactics that often blur the line between diplomacy and aggression. Employing what has been termed 'grey zone' tactics—actions that fall short of outright warfare but are aggressive enough to intimidate and harass—China aims to secure its regional hegemony. This strategy, embodied in the Chinese proverb ‘Kill the chicken to scare the monkey,’ serves as a stark warning not only to the directly affected nations but to the entire region. The message is clear: challenging China's claims could lead to severe consequences.

These tactics are not confined to the SCS. Countries far beyond the immediate region, including the United States, Japan, and even Canada, have found themselves on the receiving end of China's assertive maneuvers. Risky encounters between Chinese forces and those of other nations are becoming increasingly common, leading to heightened tensions and a growing sense of unease about China's intentions. China's aggressive stance is causing many nations to reassess their foreign policies, pushing them closer together in opposition to Beijing’s expansionist agenda.

Regional Coalition

Kelly Grieco, a Senior Fellow with the Reimagining US Grand Strategy Program, suggests that the prospects for building a regional coalition to counter Chinese aggression are significantly higher in the SCS than in the Taiwan Strait. This is because the countries involved see China's infringements on sovereignty in the SCS as directly linked to their national security interests. The increase in activity around Taiwan is viewed by many as a precursor to how China might escalate its coercive tactics in other regions, leaving nations to search for ways to rebalance their standing against what is increasingly perceived as a regional—and potentially global—bully.

The Global Impact of China’s Bullying Behavior

The territorial disputes in the SCS are not new, but China's increasingly aggressive tactics have elevated these conflicts to new heights. China’s coast guard has harassed, chased away, blocked, and occasionally attacked Vietnamese and Philippine fishermen within their EEZs. These actions, often executed by unmarked civilian vessels of China's maritime militia, are frequently backed by the China Coast Guard, which claims to be enforcing Chinese law and territory. This pattern of behavior is not isolated to the SCS; similar tactics are being employed against nations and entities worldwide that are perceived to threaten China's expanding influence.

The implications of China’s aggressive behavior extend far beyond the immediate region. Nations that might have once been ambivalent about China’s rise are now increasingly wary, viewing Beijing's actions as a threat not just to regional stability, but to global order. 

China's Disregard for International Norms

The growing list of countries that have experienced confrontations with China—whether in the SCS, the East China Sea, or elsewhere—reflects a broader trend of international resentment towards Beijing's tactics. The cumulative effect of these encounters is that China is increasingly seen not as a responsible global power, but as a nation willing to disregard international norms to achieve its strategic goals.

This shift in perception is significant. As more countries begin to view China’s actions as a direct challenge to their sovereignty and security, there is a growing consensus that something must be done to counter Beijing’s ambitions. This sentiment is not limited to the governments of the affected nations; it is also reflected in global public opinion, with increasing numbers of people around the world viewing China as a hostile power. This growing enmity could have far-reaching consequences for China’s global standing, potentially isolating it on the world stage and undermining its long-term strategic objectives.

The Role of the United States and Other Maritime Nations 

In response to China's aggressive tactics, the United States and other maritime nations have stepped up their efforts to support the SCS nations and counter Beijing's influence. The U.S., in particular, has played a pivotal role in coordinating regional and international responses to China’s actions. US Secretary of the Navy Carlos Del Toro has highlighted the importance of naval diplomacy in strengthening the network of security alliances and partnerships that the U.S. has cultivated over decades. This approach, often referred to as integrated deterrence, involves a combination of military presence, strategic partnerships, and diplomatic engagement to counter China's influence in the SCS.

Southeast Asian nations have also received significant support from other maritime powers, including Australia and Japan, who have invested in cooperative engagements and security initiatives across the region. 

Rotation of Maritime Patrols by Like-Minded Nations

As countries like the Philippines and Vietnam increase their joint patrols in the SCS, there is a growing opportunity for the U.S. to enhance these efforts by coordinating a continual rotation of ships to patrol alongside like-minded nations. This U.S.-led initiative would not only provide additional maritime capabilities but also serve as a clear signal to China that its aggressive tactics will not go unchallenged.

The U.S. Coast Guard (USCG) has also played a critical role in building the capacity of Southeast Asian maritime security forces. By rotating the deployment of cutters and sharing best practices in maritime security with countries like the Philippines, Japan, Indonesia, Singapore, South Korea, and Australia, the USCG is helping to strengthen the region’s ability to assert its sovereignty. This sustained engagement has the potential to enhance the organic capabilities of these nations, allowing them to better resist China’s coercive tactics.

However, the U.S. Navy (USN) faces challenges in adapting to the evolving security environment in the SCS. While the USN is the world’s premier “blue water” navy, the SCS nations are seeking “green water” maritime support to address the unique challenges posed by China's grey zone tactics. To better support these nations, the USN must consider how its independent deployers can receive dedicated “green water” maritime security training. Additionally, the USCG could establish a detachment in the Pacific theater, rotating crews to USN ships to enhance maritime law enforcement operations and provide specialized training to Southeast Asian partners.

China’s Global Image Problem

 As China continues to assert its claims in the SCS and beyond, it risks alienating more and more countries. The release of Beijing’s new 10-dash line map has drawn widespread condemnation from the international community, exacerbating tensions in the region and beyond. Southeast Asian nations, supported by international allies, are increasingly standing up to China’s coercive tactics, creating significant pressure on Beijing to reconsider its approach.

The global backlash against China’s actions is not just a matter of diplomatic friction; it reflects a broader concern about the kind of global power China intends to be. Countries around the world are asking whether China will respect international norms and the sovereignty of other nations, or whether it will continue to pursue its goals through bullying and intimidation. The answer to this question will have profound implications for China’s future role on the world stage.

Conclusion

China’s aggressive tactics in the SCS are not just about territorial disputes; they are part of a broader strategy that is increasingly being viewed with suspicion and hostility by the international community. As more countries experience the brunt of China’s coercive behavior, there is a growing consensus that Beijing is earning the world’s enmity. This global backlash could have significant implications for China’s strategic ambitions, potentially isolating it from the very international system it seeks to dominate. If China continues on its current path, it may find that its quest for regional hegemony has come at the cost of global friendship and cooperation.

Sources:

Aguilar, M. (2024, August 28). U.S. taking a twofold stand vs. China’s bullying in South China Sea: Coast guard admiral. Philippine Star. https://www.philstar.com/headlines/2024/08/28/2381211/us-taking-twofold-stand-vs-chinas-bullying-south-china-sea-coast-guard-admiral

Blinken, A. J. (2021, July 11). Overwhelmed by Chinese fleets Filipino fishermen ‘protest and adapt’. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/07/11/world/asia/philippines-south-china-sea-fishermen.html

Grieco, K. (2023, November 17). Philippines military accuses China of bullying and vows to continue South China Sea missions. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/nov/17/philippines-military-accuses-china-of-bullying-and-vows-to-continue-south-china-sea-missions

Nobody likes a bully: China’s grip over the South China Sea is slipping. (2023, November 15). 9DashLine. https://www.9dashline.com/article/nobody-likes-a-bully-chinas-grip-over-the-south-china-sea-is-slipping

Sugimoto, A. (2024, August 28). China keeps testing the limits of its aggression. Time. https://time.com/6302515/china-philippines-south-china-sea-aggression/

A Journey Through Vietnam: Unforgettable Moments in Ho Chi Minh City

We Visit Our Son Nik and His 

Our trip to Ho Chi Minh City was an exciting and memorable experience. We stayed with our son Nik and his wife Boots at Vinhomes Grand Park. Nik works for FPT, the largest IT company in Vietnam. Vinhomes Grand Park is beautiful, filled with modern condos, green parks, well-maintained gardens, and lovely ponds full of koi fish. Staying there felt like stepping into a peaceful oasis amidst the hustle and bustle of city life. 

The tranquility of the surroundings allowed us to unwind and truly immerse ourselves in the experience of visiting a new country. The blend of modernity and nature in Vinhomes Grand Park perfectly represents the balance Vietnam strives for—honoring the past while embracing the future.

A Birthday Dinner at The Deck Saigon

On Nik’s birthday, August 8, 2024, he and Boots took us to dinner at The Deck Saigon, a cozy and charming restaurant with an Asian fusion and vegetarian-friendly menu. The restaurant is located right by the Saigon River, just a 15-minute Grab ride from downtown Ho Chi Minh City. The setting is romantic, and the food is exceptionally well-prepared.

The gentle breeze from the river, combined with the warm lighting and the sounds of the city in the distance, created an ambiance that was both intimate and lively. A highlight of the evening was meeting a Filipino waiter who had been living in Vietnam for six years, who added a personal touch to our dining experience. His stories of adapting to life in Vietnam resonated with us and highlighted the diverse expatriate community thriving in Ho Chi Minh City. 

The Deck Saigon is famous for its excellent service, delicious international menu, and its stunning riverside location. The best time to visit is around dusk, when the sunset paints the sky in beautiful colors. During happy hour, from 4:00 to 7:00 PM, guests can enjoy half-priced cocktails from a select menu. This made the evening even more special, as we toasted to Nik’s birthday while watching the city transform under the fading sunlight. The combination of good company, great food, and an unbeatable setting made this dinner one of the highlights of our trip.

Exploring the Independence Palace

The following day, we visited the Saigon Independence Palace, also known as the Reunification Palace. This iconic landmark offers a deep dive into Vietnam's history and culture, especially during the Vietnam War. The palace features luxuriously furnished rooms, a grand exterior, and beautiful gardens. Walking through the opulent rooms, it was easy to imagine the weight of the decisions made within these walls, decisions that shaped the course of Vietnam's history. Inside, we explored various rooms and exhibits that gave us a glimpse into the lives of Vietnam’s past leaders and their roles during the war. 

The attention to detail in preserving these spaces allowed us to feel a connection to the past, as if the history was not just something to be observed, but something to be felt. The palace is a significant historical site, symbolizing the political and military struggles of southern Vietnam, and it is a must-see for history enthusiasts. The visit made me reflect on the resilience of the Vietnamese people and the complexities of war, leaving me with a deep respect for the country's history.

A Visit to the War Remnants Museum

On our third day, we visited the War Remnants Museum, which provides a sobering and educational look at the Vietnam War from the Vietnamese perspective. The museum’s exhibits include artifacts, photographs, and personal accounts that depict the harsh realities of the war, including the devastating effects of chemical weapons like Agent Orange. The displays are powerful and thought-provoking, offering visitors a deep reflection on Vietnam's turbulent history. 

As we walked through the exhibits, the images and stories stirred a mix of emotions—sadness, anger, and a profound sense of empathy. The museum does not shy away from the horrors of war, and its candid portrayal of the impact on civilians made me realize the true cost of conflict. The experience was a stark reminder of the importance of peace and the need for understanding and reconciliation in the world. It was an intense visit, but one that I believe is essential for anyone who wants to understand Vietnam’s past and its journey to the present.

Saigon Central Post Office: A Blend of Cultures

After a day of rest at Vinhomes Grand Park, we explored the Saigon Central Post Office, a must-see attraction in Ho Chi Minh City. This magnificent building is a perfect blend of neo-classical European architecture and Asian decorations. Designed by Gustave Eiffel, the architect behind the Eiffel Tower, the post office is one of the most iconic symbols of the city. 

The building features a stunning facade, a large clock that has been running for over 130 years, and two large maps that depict Saigon and its surroundings in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. 

Standing in the post office, I couldn’t help but marvel at how such a grand and functional structure could also be so artistically designed. It’s a testament to the architectural visionaries of the time who sought to create buildings that were both practical and beautiful. 

The post office’s enduring beauty and historical significance make it a vital part of Ho Chi Minh City's colonial legacy. As I explored the building, I thought about the countless letters and telegrams that must have passed through its walls, each carrying a piece of someone’s life. The post office, to me, felt like a bridge between past and present, connecting the old world of communication with the modern city that has grown around it.

We Visited HCM City Book Street

We did not miss , of course, Ho Chi Minh City's Book Street, officially known as "Đường Sách Nguyễn Văn Bình." It is a charming pedestrian street dedicated to books and literature. Nestled in the heart of the city, near landmarks like the Notre-Dame Cathedral Basilica and the Central Post Office, it offers a tranquil escape from the bustling urban environment.

The atmosphere on the street is vibrant yet serene, a perfect blend of intellectual curiosity and leisurely exploration. The street is lined with towering trees that provide ample shade, creating a cool and comfortable environment even on warmer days. 

The street is often dotted with colorful banners, book-related art installations, and murals that celebrate literature and reading. It's a place where book lovers, families, students, and tourists alike can come together to explore, relax, and indulge in their love for books.

As you stroll through the street, you'll find an array of well-organized book stalls and small shops, each offering a different selection of books. Browsing through the collections is an immersive experience. Many of the stores are beautifully designed with wooden shelves and cozy reading corners, inviting you to take your time as you explore. You can find both new releases and timeless classics, ranging from Vietnamese literature to international bestsellers.

The street offers a diverse selection of books for sale. You'll find Vietnamese literature from both contemporary and classic authors, alongside translations of popular international novels and non-fiction works. There’s also a wide variety of children’s books, including picture books, fairy tales, and educational materials. 

For those interested in more specialized topics, the street features academic and non-fiction books on subjects like history, science, business, and self-help. Additionally, comics and graphic novels, both local and international, cater to fans of visual storytelling. Art lovers can also browse beautifully crafted coffee table books on photography, architecture, and Vietnamese art.

The street is more than just a place to buy books. It’s a cultural hub where various events and activities take place regularly. You might stumble upon a book signing, a literary talk, a poetry reading, or a children's storytelling session. These events add to the street’s lively and dynamic atmosphere.

Interspersed between the book stalls are quaint little cafes where you can grab a coffee or a light snack, which we did. These cafes are often designed to complement the literary atmosphere, with comfortable seating and quiet corners perfect for reading. It's not uncommon to see people lounging with a book in one hand and a cup of coffee in the other, completely absorbed in their reading.

Overall, HCM City's Book Street is a delightful experience for anyone who loves books and culture. The atmosphere is welcoming and relaxed, making it an ideal place to spend a few hours indulging in the simple pleasure of browsing through books and soaking in the literary ambiance.

Tasting Saigon’s Street Food: Bánh Mì

No visit to Vietnam is complete without trying the local street food. Saigon's street food scene is vibrant and everywhere you go, you’ll find delicious, affordable food served in informal settings. One of the most popular street foods is bánh mì, a short baguette filled with meat and savory ingredients like mayo, a smear of rich liver pate, pickled veggies, crunchy cucumbers, spicy chilies, and fresh herbs.

It is often served as a meal. The best bánh mì can only be found in Vietnam, where it originated. The first bite of an authentic bánh mì was quite a revelation—crisp on the outside, soft and flavorful on the inside, with a perfect balance of savory and fresh ingredients.

Bánh Xèo

Another excellent Vietnamese street meal we tried was bánh xèo, also known as Vietnamese pancakes. These delightful crispy rice flour crêpes have a delicate golden brown crust with a chewy interior, featuring a lace-like appearance due to the many holes created as the batter sizzles on the hot pan. 

The name "bánh xèo" is derived from the sizzling sound the batter makes when it hits the pan. The pancakes are filled with a delicious combination of pork, shrimp, mung beans, onions, and bean sprouts, though the filling can be customized with ingredients like chicken, mushrooms, or green beans. Served hot off the grill or pan, bánh xèo is traditionally eaten by hand, wrapped in fresh herbs like cilantro, mint, and mustard greens, along with lettuce or rice paper. 

This roll is then dipped in "nuoc cham", a sweet and sour fish sauce dipping sauce, creating a harmonious blend of flavors and textures. Bánh xèo can also be enjoyed with chopsticks, offering a versatile and interactive dining experience that captures the essence of Vietnamese street food.

Pho

An iconic dish is pho, a flavorful noodle soup that can be eaten any time of the day. Pho is made with a rich broth, flat rice noodles, and thinly sliced beef or chicken, and it’s served with fresh herbs and condiments. The combination of these ingredients creates a comforting and satisfying meal that is loved by many. 

Eating street food in Saigon was more than just a culinary experience; it was a cultural one. It’s about sitting on tiny stools on the sidewalk, surrounded by the sounds and smells of the city, and sharing a meal with locals. It’s an experience that brings you closer to the heart of the city, and it’s one that we will always remember fondly.

An Unforgettable Experience

Our visit to Vietnam was truly an unforgettable experience. From the rich history and culture, we explored at the Independence Palace and War Remnants Museum to the vibrant street food scene and the charm of Saigon Central Post Office, every moment was filled with discovery and delight. The warmth of the people, the beauty of the surroundings, and the depth of the history we encountered made our trip to Vietnam one we will always cherish. 

As Loida and I reflect on our journey, we realize that Vietnam is a country of contrasts—where tradition meets modernity, where the scars of the past coexist with the hopes for the future. It’s a place that has left a lasting impression on us, and we know that the memories we made there will stay with us for the rest of our lives. 

Why Does the American Left Hate Trump?

 Introduction

The American liberal left (from now on referred to as the American Left)  is a multilayered and dynamic coalition of political parties, advocacy groups, social movements, and influential personalities. 

It works purportedly to promote progressive policies and advocates social, economic, and environmental justice. The American Left is a major influencer in the political conversation in the United States.

The Democratic Party is at the frontline of the American Left and is the primary political vehicle for liberal and left-leaning viewpoints. President Joe Biden and Vice President Kamala Harris are the leading figures within the party, speaking for mainstream liberal policies touching on economic recovery, healthcare reform, and climate action.

Although the Democratic Party as a whole supports “progressive” ideals, there is a radical wing that advocates for more drastic changes in American society. The notable figures in this faction are Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont and Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, (better known as “AOC”) of New York. 

Sanders, who describes himself as a democratic socialist, has been a vocal proponent of, among others,  Medicare for All and tuition-free college, while Ocasio-Cortez, champions the Green New Deal and social justice initiatives.

Organizations like the Justice Democrats and Our Revolution further make up the American Left.  The Justice Democrats, a political action committee, supports progressive candidates such as Representative Cori Bush of Missouri. Representative Bush is campaigning to raise awareness about racial and economic injustices.

Our Revolution, founded by Bernie Sanders, is an offshoot of Sanders’ 2016 presidential campaign and advocates for grassroots engagement and progressive policies. Nina Turner, a former state senator in Ohio, is the president of Our Revolution. The organization is dedicated to reshaping the political landscape through progressive reforms.

Various personalities figure in the American Left. Senator Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts advocates for consumer protection and economic equality, while Representative Pramila Jayapal of Washington, who chairs the Congressional Progressive Caucus, strongly supports healthcare and immigration reforms. Representative Ro Khanna of California focuses on technological advancements and economic justice, further expanding the American Left’s policy priorities.

Advocacy and think tank groups provide intellectual and organizational support to the American Left. MoveOn.org is a prominent progressive public policy advocacy group and political action committee that mobilizes voters and advocates for a wide range of issues, from healthcare to climate change. The Center for American Progress is another influential entity, conducting research and promoting progressive ideas to shape public policy.

The American Left is closely connected with Black Lives Matter (BLM), a movement that focuses on racism, discrimination, and racial inequality experienced by black people. It was co-founded by Patrisse Cullors, Alicia Garza, and Opal Tometi. BLM has played a crucial role in highlighting racial injustices and pushing for police reform. 

Likewise, the Sunrise Movement, led by executive director Varshini Prakash, mobilizes young people to demand urgent action on climate change and advocates for policies like the Green New Deal. The Democratic Socialists of America (DSA), with key figures such as Bhaskar Sunkara, founder of Jacobin magazine, promotes democratic socialism as a way to achieve economic and social justice.

Media personalities and influencers also contribute significantly to the American Left discourse. Rachel Maddow, a host on MSNBC, provides a progressive perspective on current events, while Jon Stewart, a comedian and former host of "The Daily Show," uses satire to critique conservative politics and highlight social issues. Documentary filmmaker and author Michael Moore is known for his incisive critiques of corporate America and advocacy for progressive causes.

Cultural and academic influences further enrich the American Left landscape. Noam Chomsky, a linguist, philosopher, and political activist, is celebrated for his critiques of capitalism and U.S. foreign policy. Also, Cornel West, a philosopher, political activist, and author, proffers profound insights into race, class, and social justice, adding to the intellectual foundation of the American Left.

What Then Motivates the American Left to Hate Donald J. Trump?

The American Left’s hostility to Donald Trump is rooted in differences in ideology, policy, and values. These factors combined have led to fear and loathing of Trump from the former, who view his policies and behavior as extremely antithetical to their values and the direction they believe the country should take. 

Some of the dominant reasons are:

1. Immigration: Trump's hardline stance on immigration, including the construction of the border wall and family separation policies, contrasts sharply with the American Left’s position on more humane and inclusive immigration policies. Under the Trump administration, the US government had a "zero-tolerance" policy that allowed authorities to deport adults who crossed the border illegally. In some cases, parents were deported back to their home countries without their children, who were placed in government custody.

2. Climate Change: the Trump administration’s withdrawal from the Paris Agreement and its deregulation of environmental protections are seen as harmful by the American Left, which prioritizes environmental sustainability and climate action. Trump's withdrawal increased the carbon price for other countries while reducing the US’ carbon price. When the withdrawal took effect, the U.S. was the only United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) member state that was not a signatory to the Paris Agreement.

3. Healthcare: The Trump administration’s efforts to repeal the Affordable Care Act (ACA) and its changes to Medicaid and Medicare are opposed by American Left-liberals who advocate for expanded healthcare access. In the present campaign, Trump has made it clear that his goal remains to repeal the Affordable Care Act (ACA), including its expansion of Medicaid to low-income adults, and to impose rigid caps on the federal government’s Medicaid spending.

4. LGBTQ+ Rights: Trump administration actions such as the ban on transgender individuals serving in the military and the rollback of protections for LGBTQ+ people are viewed as regressive by American Left-liberals who support equality and anti-discrimination measures. In its first year (2017), the Trump administration tried to reinstate a ban on transgender people in the military. It nominated multiple people to the courts and elsewhere who have anti-LGBTQ records. It directed its army of federal lawyers to take the anti-LGBTQ side in court cases.

5. Reproductive Rights: Trump’s appointment of conservative justices to the Supreme Court, which has led to increased threats to Roe v. Wade, is opposed by American Left-liberals who support abortion rights. Trump said his actions have “put the Pro-Life movement in a strong negotiating position” against proponents of abortion rights, giving himself credit for the various bans that are being advanced by conservatives across the country. More than a dozen states have enacted abortion limits since the US Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade in the summer of 2023.

6. Divisive Rhetoric and Behavior: Trump’s often inflammatory and divisive language, particularly on issues of race, ethnicity, and religion, is seen by the American Liberal-Left as fostering division and hate. They view his behavior, including his use of social media and public statements, as unpresidential and damaging to the dignity of the office. CNN, a vociferous Trump critic, has said that Trump’s extreme rhetoric is reminiscent of Nazi propaganda and his penchant for what it sees as taking the side of America’s adversaries poses a unique challenge to his Republican opponents and, ultimately, the American people.

7. Disregard for Norms and Institutions: The American Left views Trump’s attacks on the press, judiciary, and other institutions as undermining democratic norms and the rule of law. It is alarmed by what it sees as Trump's disregard for the rule of law and his perceived attempts to undermine democratic norms and institutions. In the eyes of the American Left, Trump has been following a consistent playbook in his attacks on the judges, court staff, witnesses, and opposing lawyers involved in his many civil and criminal trials. They accuse him of seeking to subvert the system by using its mechanisms for his ends and to avoid having his day in court, rather than facing a judge and jury.

8. Alliances and Diplomacy: Trump's approach to traditional alliances such as NATO, his strained relationships with traditional allies, and his interactions with authoritarian leaders are seen by the American Left as weakening the global standing and values of the United States and contrary to its vision of collaborative international relations. According to them, the Trump administration’s words and actions have taken a toll on US foreign policy, the prospects for U.S. leadership in the world, and the health and security of Americans. Furthermore, the American Left says US diplomats report they cannot effectively champion human rights or promote good governance because of the President's example.

9. Trade Policies: Trump’s trade wars, particularly with China, have been criticized by the American Left for adversely impacting global trade and economic stability. The trade war with China, according to them, has caused economic hurt on both sides and has led to the diversion of trade flows away from both China and the United States. Heather Long of the Washington Post wrote: “U.S. economic growth slowed, business investment froze, and companies didn’t hire as many people. Across the nation, many farmers went bankrupt, and the manufacturing and freight transportation sectors hit lows not seen since the last recession.”

10. Tax Cuts: The 2017 tax cuts, which are seen as disproportionately benefiting the wealthy and corporations, are opposed by the American Left who promote more progressive taxation and wealth redistribution. New research shows the corporate rate cut overwhelmingly benefited top earners and executives, failing to trickle down to rank-and-file workers. The available evidence suggests that this tax cut has indeed not provided substantial advantages for regular workers.

11. Regulation: Deregulation efforts, particularly in financial, environmental, and labor markets, are seen by the American Left as favoring big businesses at the expense of consumer and worker protections. They say President Trump often used executive orders as a centerpiece of his deregulatory agenda and often ordered U.S. federal agencies to rescind regulations. The American Left’s position is that Trump’s “corporate presidency” delivered benefits to businesses, but harmed the public.

12. Transparency and Accountability: Issues such as the handling of the Mueller investigation, the Ukraine scandal leading to his impeachment, and concerns about conflicts of interest and personal gain are viewed by the American Left as indicative of corruption and a lack of accountability under the Trump administration. Some of its observers say the administration took important policy steps to improve the way agencies collect and share data. Still, others cite an abysmal record in releasing information related to policy decisions and activities on immigration enforcement, environmental protection, climate science, and other contentious issues.

13. Racial Inequality: The American Left perceives Trump's rhetoric and policies as exacerbating racial tensions and undermining civil rights. His handling of issues related to police brutality and his response to movements like BLM have been particularly provocative. Some had hoped he would moderate his tone in office, but during his four years, they aver that Trump had inflamed racial tensions even more — through both rhetoric and policy. They further contend that Trump heavily favored existing American prejudices, oftentimes times using racist language and dog whistles, and has repeatedly failed to denounce white supremacy.

14. Women's Rights: The American Left denounces Trump's inconsistent stance on reproductive rights, including his efforts to restrict access to abortion by causing the question to be thrown to the states, and his appointments of conservative justices to the Supreme Court who have struck down Roe v. Wade. To them, few issues epitomize the astonishing nature of Donald J. Trump’s political comeback as his stand on abortion. Over the past two decades, Trump’s public statements on one of the most divisive American issues have swung like a pendulum, to his political advantage. In response, Trump has compared his shifting stand on abortion to that of Republican icon and former President Ronald Reagan.

15. Labor Rights: Trump's policies are seen by the American Left as favoring businesses over workers, with less emphasis on labor rights, fair wages, and workplace protections. The American Left contends that from Trump’s first day in office, he systematically promoted the interests of corporate executives and shareholders over those of working people. Furthermore, they charge that Trump rolled back worker protections, proposed budgets that slash funding for agencies that safeguard workers’ rights, wages, and safety, and consistently attacked workers’ ability to organize and collectively bargain. 

16. Response to the Covid Crisis: The American Left has criticized President Trump's handling of the COVID-19 pandemic. It perceives his response as inadequate, dismissive of scientific advice, and harmful to public health. In particular, the American Left has decried Trump’s failure to mount a timely and effective response to the COVID‐19 outbreak, despite ample warning. They avow that the Trump administration underestimated the coronavirus threat and responded slowly and botched the federal response.

References:

Brookings. (2021, July 23). Have Democrats become a party of the left? Retrieved from https://www.brookings.edu

Brookings. (2021). The political typology: In polarized era, deep divisions persist within coalitions of both Democrats and Republicans. Retrieved from https://www.pewresearch.org

Brookings. (2020). The Trump administration’s major environmental deregulations. Retrieved from https://www.brookings.edu

Columbia University. (2021). The Paris Climate Agreement: What Trump’s decision to leave means. Retrieved from https://news.climate.columbia.edu

Grantham Research Institute. (2017, June 5). Trump’s withdrawal from the Paris Agreement: What next for international climate policy?. Retrieved from https://www.lse.ac.uk

Long, H. (2020). U.S. economic growth slowed, business investment froze, and companies didn’t hire as many people. The Washington Post. Retrieved from https://www.washingtonpost.com

National Geographic. (2020). 15 ways the Trump administration has impacted the environment. Retrieved from https://www.nationalgeographic.com

United States Department of State. (2020). On the U.S. withdrawal from the Paris Agreement. Retrieved from https://2017-2021.state.gov